The Bachelor, The Caretaker, The Accidental Matchmaker

By J. L. Starkey

There are only two kinds of people in the world.

The Irish and those who wish they were.

-Irish Saying

I stared at the page in frustration, certain that I had made an error. The 1887 Washington, D.C., marriage index couldn’t be for my great-great-grandparents, William and Melcena Baugh. After all, my Melcena was a Chicago native who lived in the Midwest her entire life. The Melcena listed in this index was born in Chicago, but she lived in Richmond, Virginia, at the time of her marriage to William.

Did I find the correct couple?

As it so happens, I did. And I have my bachelor uncle, George Payne O’Neill, to thank for that.

The O’Neill Surprises Continue

Scotch Street, Armagh, Northern Ireland, ca. 1900 [National Library of Ireland on The Commons, No restrictions,]

“Did you know that the O’Neill family was from Northern Ireland?” I had been waiting all week to spring that question on my mom. She knew she had Irish roots, but she thought her ancestors were from Cork and Tipperary. She told us that the rest of her family was, “…oh, some Danish…and probably English.”

So this new locale? This was a find.

English Street, Armagh, ca. 1900
[Public domain image]

In college, one of my favorite courses was Professor Rhys Williams’ “Comparative Racial and Ethnic Relations.” The lectures and discussions helped me to understand how Ireland became so divided during certain eras [1].

Given what I learned in that class, I had to wonder just how awkward the holidays were for my Irish ancestors, but that may be a story for another time [2].

I’m getting ahead of myself. Let’s go back to 1845, so that I can properly introduce my bachelor-uncle-turned-accidental-matchmaker.

Uncle George Serves His Country

George Payne O’Neill family tree

Born in Mount Vernon, Ohio, in 1845, George Payne O’Neill II was the youngest son of Armagh, Northern Ireland, native George Payne O’Neill I and Melcena (Irvine) O’Neill [3]. The older brother of Gabriella, George had a close relationship with his sister, and he even served as witness to one of her three marriages [4].

Levee Street, Brownsville, Texas from the pontoon bridge
across the Rio Grande,Nov 1866 [5]

By all accounts, George was a hard worker who supported his mother and siblings, perhaps because his brothers refused – or were unable – to do so [6]. Just one day after his nineteenth birthday, he enlisted in the Ohio Volunteer Infantry, and he served as a musician during the final years of the Civil War. After his discharge at Brownsville, Texas, he joined his family in Chicago and found work as a carriage trimmer [7].

Dearborn Street, Chicago, ca. 1860 [Public domain stereograph photos]

By 1870, perhaps sensing that hard times were ahead for his employer, George moved to Jackson, Mississippi, where he found work as a wagon maker [8]. By 1874, he had returned to Chicago, was still single, and was working as an upholsterer [9].

Though Uncle George appeared to be a confirmed bachelor, by 1882 he was actually a divorcee. His ill-fated March 1880 marriage to Alberta Baker lasted less than two years on paper and less than 90 days in reality. By the time of the 1880 census, George, who was again living with his mother and siblings, reported himself as single. That life seemed to suit him best, and he never remarried.

Uncle George the Matchmaker

By 1886, George had again left Chicago. Although he returned by the early 1890s, I couldn’t account for those missing four years. At the same time, I questioned how his future nephew-in-law, the southern-born William Baugh, ended up living in post-reconstruction Chicago. William had no connections to the area, and none of his siblings had made such a drastic move.

Where was the missing puzzle piece? I knew that, like George, William worked as an upholsterer in Chicago [10]. I also knew that George and William shared a business – and a residence – from the early 1890s until George’s death in 1914 [11].

But where did the men meet?

To find that answer, I turned to one of my favorite resources: the directory.

If William and Melcena had indeed married in D.C., I theorized that a member of Melcena’s family must have had a connection to the area [12]. Based on that assumption, I searched Richmond and Washington, D.C., directories for variations of the O’Neill surname.

My suspicions were correct. In 1886, William Baugh was living in Richmond and working as an upholsterer. And guess who was also working as an upholsterer while living with William’s father, Everett [13]? It was none other than bachelor uncle, George O’Neill!

The missing puzzle pieces: 1886 directory listings for George O’Neill and William Baugh

Though the actual “how they met” story will never be known, I assume that William met Melcena when she stayed with her Uncle George at Everett Baugh’s home. The couple must have had a whirlwind courtship; on July 4, 1887, they married in Washington, D.C. They then moved to Fredericksburg, where William and George opened O’Neill & Baugh, a cabinet and upholstery shop [14]. The men would run the business together – first in Fredericksburg and then in Chicago – until George O’Neill’s death in 1914.

George P. O’Neill obituary [The Chicago Daily Tribune, 1 Dec 1914]

About those awkward family dinners…

There seem to be two camps of family history researchers: those who do research collateral lines, and those who do not. I am in the first camp and make no apologies for my journeys down ancestral rabbit holes. Yes, it is time consuming, and sometimes that extra research does nothing to break down a brick wall.

But then there are those other times…and that is what makes it all worthwhile.

I am so happy that I got to take a peek into the life of George Payne O’Neill. Bachelor uncle, businessman, would-be matchmaker? Uncle George was all three of those things. Were it not for him and his accidental matchmaking, there’s a pretty good chance that I wouldn’t be here today!

And it’s just a hunch, but I would bet that he was darn proud of his Irish heritage at all of those awkward family dinners.


  1. Rhys H. Williams, PhD, is now Director of the McNamara Center for the Social Study of Religion, Loyola University Chicago. You can learn more about him at
  2. For a brief overview of Ireland’s turbulent history, see:
  3. “Illinois, Cook County Deaths, 1878-1994,” database, FamilySearch ( : 8 Mar 2018), George Payne O Neill, 30 Nov 1914; citing Chicago, Cook, Illinois, United States, source reference 14238, record number , Cook County Courthouse, Chicago; FHL microfilm 1,239,986.
  4. Presbyterian Historical Society; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania; Book Title: Register 1858-1885; Accession Number: Vault BX 9211 .N74202 C32 v.1.
  5. Louis De Planque in Thompson, Jerry, and Lawrence T. Jones III, Civil War & Revolution on the Rio Grande Frontier. Austin: Texas State Historical Association, 2004. Public domain image,
    Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division, Washington, D.C. 20540,
  6. An example is found in the 1870 census for George’s brother Thomas, an inmate at the Illinois State Penitentiary:
    Joliet, Will, Illinois; Roll: M593_291; Page: 149B; FHL microfilm: 545790.
  7. “United States Veterans Administration Pension Payment Cards, 1907-1933,” database with images, FamilySearch ( : 22 May 2014), O’Neill, Abby – Opocensky, Frank W.>image 114 of 684; citing NARA microfilm publication M850 (Washington, D.C.: NARA, n.d.). (See also: Historical Data Systems, comp. U.S., Civil War Soldier Records and Profiles, 1861-1865 [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Operations Inc, 2009; and Chicago, Illinois, City Directory, 1867. p. 679, col. 1. Retrieved from U.S. City Directories, 1822-1995 [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Operations, Inc., 2011.)
  8. 1870 United States Census, Jackson, Hinds, Mississippi; Roll: M593_730; Page: 748A; FHL microfilm: 552229.
  9. Chicago, Illinois, City Directory, 1874. p. 840, col. 2. Retrieved from U.S. City Directories, 1822-1995 [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Operations, Inc., 2011.
  10. Chicago, Illinois, City Directory, 1890. p. 1668, col. 1. Retrieved from U.S. City Directories, 1822-1995 [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Operations, Inc., 2011.
  11. Illinois, Cook County Deaths 1878–1922.” Index. FamilySearch, Salt Lake City, Utah, 2010. Illinois Department of Public Health. “Birth and Death Records, 1916–present.” Division of Vital Records, Springfield, Illinois.
  12. “District of Columbia Marriages, 1811-1950,” database with images, FamilySearch ( : 11 February 2018), William Everitt Bough and Malcena Angeline Millison, 04 Jul 1887; citing p. 10432, Records Office, Washington D.C.; FHL microfilm 2,025,891.
  13. Richmond, Virginia, City Directory, 1886, p. 317, col. 1, and p. 118, col. 2. Retrieved from U.S. City Directories, 1822-1995 [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Operations, Inc., 2011.
  14. Chataigne’s Fredericksburg and Falmouth City Directory, 1888-’89. Electronic version created by the Center for Historic Preservation, Mary Washington College, Original on file at Central Rappahannock Regional Library (CRRL), Fredericksburg, Virginia.

5 thoughts on “The Bachelor, The Caretaker, The Accidental Matchmaker

Add yours

  1. Wow!! You’ve done it again. You really need to make this into a novel….

    On Fri, Mar 8, 2019, 1:24 PM Baugh, Bass, and Beyond wrote:

    > J. L. Starkey posted: ” By J. L. Starkey English Street, Armagh, Northern > Ireland, ca. 1900. (Public domain photo) ”There are only two kinds of > people in the world. The Irish and those who wish they were.”Irish Saying I > stared at the page in frustration, certain that I” >


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a website or blog at

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: