By J. L. Starkey
And now I'm glad I didn't know
The way it all would end
The way it all would go
Our lives are better left to chance
I could have missed the pain
But I'd have to miss the dance
- Tony Arata
“This is my mother,” grandma said as she pointed to a beautiful photo in an old album. “Her name was Mabel…she was sixteen when this was taken.” She paused to take a sip of her tea, then continued. “Now, she was a Fisher before she married my dad, you know. His name was Ruell, but everyone called him Bert.” Another pause, another sip, and then, “Now, Mabel’s mother…my grandmother? Her name was Esther, and…”
That picture of Mabel was the first family photo that grandma shared with me, and it remains one of my favorites. I see so much hope in Mabel’s eyes, and confidence too. It is the photo of a young woman ready to take on the world. It is, quite simply, her defining image.
It’s interesting to look at a photo when you already know what the future holds for the individual pictured in it. I knew that Mabel would give birth to sixteen (yes…sixteen!) children, and that she would help her husband manage the family farm. Additionally, since grandma was never one to sugarcoat things, I knew that Mabel would endure more than her share of tragedy in the years after she posed for that portrait.
I was a lucky kid, because I had a grandma who was always willing to tell a story or two (or five) about her family. Sometimes she would try to name all of her siblings for us, just for fun. (She would usually slow down when she got to Oscar or Donald, and then she would consult her pictures or notes for a hint.) Over the years, we heard bits and pieces about the lives of all of her siblings. We knew about Cleo, the one with the perfect complexion, and we knew about Lena, the career woman. We also knew about Morris, the family historian, and Cecil, the retired master sergeant. Oh, and don’t forget Nita (or maybe it was Violet?), the really funny sister with the good fashion sense…and so it went.
Sadly, we also knew about the brother who died in the flood. In her later years, Grandma had trouble remembering his name and the circumstances surrounding his tragic death. Years later, when I researched Mabel’s life, I made it a goal to learn the rest of her story, tragedies and all.
And it turned out that Grandma was (almost) correct.
Tragedy at Badger Creek
Born on 22 July 1911, Justus Willard Rowe, the eleventh child of Mabel and Bert, was named after Mabel’s father, Justus Fisher. Just two days before his thirteenth birthday, he drowned in a boating accident on Badger Creek in Cowley County, Kansas. The story went out on the Associated Press wire, but the name of the deceased was reported as Richard instead of Justus. I wondered if the error was made deliberately in an effort to protect the family’s privacy. Winfield newspapers did not run the story at all, perhaps out of compassion for this well-known and respected family.
Justus Rowe was just twelve years old at the time of his death. Today, I am the mother of a twelve-year-old son. When I think about the tragedy in those terms, it hits very close to home, and my heart breaks for Mabel. She had at least eight children living at home in 1924, and her youngest child had just turned three when she lost her son on that terrible July day.
I wondered what her life was like after that day. Was she given the privacy and time to mourn? Did she have the support of her husband and her older children? How did she go on living in the wake of such sadness? I assumed that she rarely – if ever – talked about it, and perhaps that was why my grandmother did not remember the incident with a great deal of clarity.
Illness, Loss, and Unspeakable Grief
While grandma provided amazing details in most of her stories, she did not do that when she discussed her father’s death. She simply told me that Mabel outlived Bert by several years, and moved on to another story. It was not until I was a teenager that I would learn that the fear of losing all he had worked for had driven Bert to make a desperate – and irreversible – decision.
My father was calm and matter of fact as he discussed the circumstances of Bert’s death. He told me that the family was facing the loss of their farm, but Bert believed that the government “would not put a widow off of her land.” According to dad, Bert felt like he had no other choice, so he took his own life, leaving Mabel and his children to ask the one question that had no answer: why?
My search for answers led to a news article that went out on the AP wire the day after Bert’s death. While that story provided details, the facts were quite different from the ones my father shared with me. Which story was correct? Did they both have shades of truth? Or were both versions completely false?
Sometimes, genealogy does not lead us to answers, and that is the case with this chapter of my family history. While I know parts of the story, the actual circumstances that led to Bert Rowe’s suicide will never be known. I am certain, though, that Mabel did not care one bit about keeping a farm that came at the cost of her husband’s life. Perhaps she would have echoed the words of author Marcus Sedgwick, and reminded him that:
“There’s always a third choice in life. Even if you think you’re stuck between two impossible choices, there’s always a third way. You just have to look for it.”– Revolver, by Marcus Sedgwick
The first draft of “Her Defining Image” did not include the details of Bert Rowe’s death. However, after reading about John Besner at https://www.yourmomgenes.com/my-blog/john-besnerone-photo-and-short-life?onlyContent=1, I decided to tell the rest of Mabel’s story (both good and bad). Thank you, Carrie, for sharing your family’s story, and for giving me the courage to do the same.
The National Suicide Prevention Lifeline provides free and confidential emotional support to people in suicidal crisis or emotional distress 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, across the United States.Call 1-800-273-TALK (8255) at any time for help.